| Platinum | Crumbl Cookies |
| Gold | Omg! Cupcakes |
| Silver | Grandin Bakery (1976) |
| Bronze | Italian Bakery's Mercato |
| Top Pick | Carmela's Whisk Bakery and Cafe |
| Top Pick | Confections cake co. |
| Top Pick | Macaron and Goodies |
| Top Pick | Pearson's Your Independent Grocer |
| Top Pick | Sugarhugcookieco |
| Top Pick | Wild Earth Bakery |